generated 19 Nov 2026 11:26 WIB

Does a positioning portfolio of three long and three short rules beat holding BTC from 2025?

FRAME

BET

A portfolio of the best positioning rules is more efficient than holding BTC out of sample.

KILL

test falsified if result status
portfolio Calmar out of sample <= 0.00 0.51 pass

Portfolio: dev total +197.0%, max drawdown 13.6, Calmar 14.52; out of sample total +6.6%, max drawdown 12.9, Calmar 0.51. Holding BTC: dev +292.1% / 125.9 / 2.32; out of sample -1.5% / 69.3 / -0.02.

Rules (top5_share = share of the rule's dev result from its 5 best trades):

rule dev_trades dev_plateau dev_calmar top5_share oos_trades oos_total oos_calmar
long: global_ls <= p50 and taker_share_24h >= p90 155 11.83 15.82 23% 96 -2.6 -0.09
long: global_ls <= p60 and ret_24h <= p60 254 8.96 9.86 20% 100 -10.1 -0.21
long: funding_chg_24h >= p50 and oi_vs_7d <= p30 291 6.51 6.51 36% 110 +31.2 0.86
short: oi_vs_7d >= p90 and global_ls_chg_24h >= p70 98 5.88 7.55 49% 13 +14.3 1.39
short: oi_chg_24h >= p60 and global_ls_chg_24h >= p90 160 3.48 3.32 53% 55 +8.1 0.30
short: funding_chg_24h >= p90 and taker_share_24h <= p20 74 1.95 2.53 84% 6 -1.1 -0.11

By year (% of capital, summed):

year portfolio_pct hold_btc_pct
2020 +34.0 +94.5
2021 +68.0 +83.7
2022 +21.9 -82.5
2023 +26.0 +103.1
2024 +47.1 +93.2
2025 +3.0 +3.3
2026 +3.6 -4.8

Placebo, reported not deciding: the whole pipeline on 10 shifted datasets gave portfolio dev Calmar median 8.40, max 19.01; real 14.52.

UPDATE