generated 19 Nov 2026 11:26 WIB

Is a BTC grid whose side follows LB6 more efficient than a plain grid on the holdout?

FRAME

BET

A grid whose side follows LB6 is more efficient than the better plain grid.

KILL

All three grids ran once on the holdout with identical parameters.

test falsified if result status
Calmar, LB6-directed <= 0.65 (neutral) 2.22 pass

Also observed, not deciding:

variant total_pct max_dd_pts max_dd_at calmar volume_usd round_trips executors ends_tp_stop_dir breakeven_maker_fee_pct
LB6-directed +8.88 4.00 2026-03-29 2.22 136,575 518 152 33/13/106 +0.1021
neutral +4.87 7.53 2026-08-25 0.65 231,801 1802 205 109/94/0 +0.0463
long-only +4.10 10.48 2026-06-24 0.39 231,590 886 107 57/49/0 +0.0422

executors counts every grid started; ends counts those that ended before the window closed (a grid still running at the end is in the first number only). Max drawdown dates are the trough; LB6-directed fell from +4.48 (2026-02-28) to +0.48 (2026-03-29).

Post-hoc check (run after the result was seen; not part of the bet): same on/off timing as LB6 with the side reversed: total -15.00%, Calmar -0.86. Same timing with a random side per LB6 stretch, 10 seeds: Calmar median -0.25 (min -0.84, max 0.89); total median -1.58%; 0 of 10 reach LB6's Calmar; 1 of 10 beat the neutral grid.

Post-hoc, sensitivity to the end of the window: up to 2026-08-18 (before BTC's last-week rally), LB6-directed total +9.04%, max drawdown 4.00, Calmar 2.26; neutral total +11.47%, max drawdown 5.55, Calmar 2.07. Most of the margin on the full window comes from the final week, where the neutral grid's SELL half lost.

An independent re-implementation from the same written spec and the Hummingbot source (subagent, no shared code, ~/.cache/claude-work/xcheck-grid/grid.py) reproduced all three variants' total, max drawdown, Calmar and volume to the shown precision.

Volume per 30 days per 1,000 USDT: LB6-directed 19,890; neutral 33,758; long-only 33,727.

UPDATE