generated 19 Nov 2026 11:26 WIB

Do LB6's stop-losses pay for themselves?

FRAME

BET

Removing the stop-losses makes Config B more efficient.

KILL

Both variants replayed with the oracle; only the stop differs. Entries are identical (337 matched trades).

test falsified if result status
Calmar, mark-to-market no stop <= 27.99 11.85 FAIL

Also observed, not deciding:

variant trades sl_exits total mtm_max_dd mtm_dd_trough closed_max_dd calmar_mtm worst_trade
Config B 337 19 +239.4 8.6 2025-12-08 9.7 27.99 -8.10
no stop 337 0 +242.5 20.5 2026-08-25 24.4 11.85 -23.53

Per engine:

engine_id stop_pct n sl_exits total_stop total_nostop change
FOCUSED_TOP_SHARPE 4.0 36 2 +44.9 +54.1 +9.2
deepdw_iv_M04 4.5 33 0 +21.3 +21.3 +0.0
deepput_strike_C14_G09 3.5 67 10 +32.4 +38.8 +6.3
dw_tail_C04 7.0 41 0 +34.5 +34.5 +0.0
iv_deepcall_0804_SL8 8.0 58 2 +40.4 +48.8 +8.3
netdw_skew_C01 5.0 102 5 +66.0 +45.2 -20.8

Excluding the worst trade's window (from 2026-08-17 17:00 UTC, netdw_skew_C01 short, -23.53% without a stop): mark-to-market max drawdown 8.55 (2025-12-08) vs 13.24 (2026-06-05); the drawdown is still deeper without stops.

Prices: entries and native exits use the options-data spot; stop and take-profit checks and the hourly mark-to-market use Binance 1h bars (Binance Vision); only forced closes (data gaps, end of data) use merged_btc_hourly_FROZEN.csv, which ends 2026-07-14. One forced close falls after that: the worst trade above, closed at the end of data (2026-08-26 04:00 UTC), priced at the Binance 1h open for that hour (79,088.61, checked against the Binance Vision daily file). Last entry is 2026-08-22; the last exit is 2026-08-26. An independent re-implementation (subagent, no shared code) produced the same Calmar values.

The 19 stopped trades, with and without the stop (12 would have ended better without it, 1 of them by less than 0.1 pts; "saved" = with stop minus without, positive = the stop helped):

engine_id entry net_pct_stop net_pct_nostop reason_nostop saved
netdw_skew_C01 2025-05-08 -5.10 -5.41 native_close +0.31
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2025-06-01 -3.60 +0.13 native_close -3.73
netdw_skew_C01 2025-07-10 -5.10 -5.08 native_close -0.02
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2025-10-10 -3.60 -8.93 native_close +5.33
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2025-10-17 -3.60 -1.62 native_close -1.98
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2025-11-13 -3.60 -6.26 native_close +2.66
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2025-11-20 -3.60 -1.31 native_close -2.29
FOCUSED_TOP_SHARPE 2025-12-06 -4.10 +2.90 TP -7.00
netdw_skew_C01 2026-01-10 -5.10 -4.39 native_close -0.71
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2026-02-05 -3.60 +6.40 TP -10.00
FOCUSED_TOP_SHARPE 2026-02-13 -4.10 -1.87 native_close -2.23
netdw_skew_C01 2026-03-03 -5.10 -7.89 native_close +2.79
iv_deepcall_0804_SL8 2026-03-05 -8.10 -3.34 native_close -4.76
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2026-03-27 -3.60 -3.23 native_close -0.37
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2026-06-01 -3.60 -5.96 native_close +2.36
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2026-06-03 -3.60 -6.31 native_close +2.71
iv_deepcall_0804_SL8 2026-06-15 -8.10 -4.53 native_close -3.57
deepput_strike_C14_G09 2026-07-23 -3.60 -2.56 native_close -1.04
netdw_skew_C01 2026-08-17 -5.10 -23.53 native_close +18.43

UPDATE