generated 19 Nov 2026 10:57 WIB

Does the best simple rule on trader positioning beat holding BTC?

No. The best of 3,888 rules looked far better than luck on 2020 to 2024, and then lost 20% on the 22 months it had never seen, while simply holding BTC lost 2%. Its edge on 2020 to 2024 came almost entirely from stepping aside during the 2022 crash, and did not repeat.

What was searched

PekkaLabs's LB6 system trades BTC with rules of a simple shape: "go long when measure A is above some level and measure B is below some level". Its measures come from options trading. This search used the same shape on four public measures of how BTC futures traders are positioned, from Binance's archive:

Each rule takes two of the four, a cut-off for each (from the 10th to the 90th percentile of its values), a direction for each (above or below), and a side (long or short). A position opens the hour after the rule is true and closes 24 hours after it was last true. Fees (0.05% each way) and funding payments are included. That makes 3,888 rules.

Everything, including how the winner would be judged, was written down and agreed before the search ran. The period from January 2025 to October 2026 was kept untouched for one final test.

The best rule on 2020 to 2024

Long BTC when open interest has not fallen more than 2.8% in 24 hours and the long/short account ratio is at most 1.72. In plain words: hold BTC, except when many more accounts are long than short, or when positions are being closed fast.

From September 2020 to December 2024 it made +396% with a worst fall of 31 points (percentage points of capital): an efficiency (return divided by worst fall, called Calmar in the compact view) of 12.8. Rules needed at least 71 trades to count, so that about 30 would fall in the final test. Holding BTC made +292% with a worst fall of 126 points, efficiency 2.3.

Far better than luck on that data

The best of 3,888 rules will always look good by chance. To measure how good chance looks, the same search was run 100 more times on scrambled data: the four measures were shifted in time against the price by at least 30 days, so their own patterns stayed but no longer lined up with the price.

best rule vs luck

The best scrambled rule scored 5.8 in a typical run and 10.1 at most. The real winner, 12.8, beat all 100. Rules with slightly different cut-offs also did well (efficiency 7.3 to 12.4). The locked check only asked that their middle value be above zero, a weak bar, but they cleared it easily. Both checks passed, so the rule went to the final test.

On data it had never seen, it lost

blind test

From January 2025 to October 2026 the rule lost 19.9%, with a worst fall of 52 points, on 60 trades. Holding BTC ended at -1.5% with a worst fall of 69 points. The rule's efficiency was -0.38, below both holding BTC (-0.02) and zero, so the bet failed. (Efficiency below zero is awkward to compare, since a deeper fall makes it less negative; here the rule both lost more and fell less deep than holding, and failed either way.)

Why it passed the checks and still failed

The scrambled runs used the same BTC prices, so they already enjoyed the same rising market; a rising market alone cannot explain why the real rule beat them. A check made after the result points elsewhere: the rule's edge came almost entirely from one year.

year time in a position BTC while in BTC while out
2020 (Sep to Dec) 95% +105% -11%
2021 47% +113% -29%
2022 63% +14% -96%
2023 74% +102% +1%
2024 78% +110% -16%
2025 80% -17% +20%

BTC moves here are hourly moves added up, not compounded, so they can pass -100%.

The rule mostly holds BTC and steps aside when many more accounts are long than short. In the 2022 crash, stepping aside avoided most of the fall: 96 of the 151 points it avoided over 2020 to 2024. In other years stepping aside mattered little, and in 2025 it was wrong, missing a 20-point rise. One episode, not a lasting pattern, carried the rule past the checks. The scrambled runs could not catch this because they measure how good the best rule can look by chance, not whether its gains are spread over time.

What it means

Limits