generated 19 Nov 2026 11:26 WIB

Does the best two-measure positioning rule beat holding BTC on blind data?

FRAME

BET

The best positioning rule found on dev is more efficient than holding BTC on blind data.

KILL

Winner on dev: long when oi_chg_24h >= -2.79 (p20) and global_ls <= 1.716 (p60); 163 trades, total +396.0%, max drawdown 31.0, Calmar 12.79. Holding BTC on dev: total +292.1%, Calmar 2.32.

test falsified if result status
dev: winner Calmar vs placebo p95 <= 9.27 12.79 pass
dev: median Calmar of threshold neighbours <= 0 9.11 pass
holdout: winner Calmar <= 0.00 (max of buy-and-hold, 0) -0.38 FAIL

Placebo best Calmar over 100 runs: median 5.77, 95th percentile 9.27, max 10.11; real winner above 100 of 100.

Holdout 2025-01-01 to 2026-10-31: rule total -19.9%, max drawdown 52.3, Calmar -0.38, 60 trades; holding BTC total -1.5%, max drawdown 69.3, Calmar -0.02.

Post-hoc diagnosis (after the result): share of hours in a position, and BTC's summed hourly return while in vs out of a position: dev: in market 68%, BTC return in +443.5%, out -151.4%; holdout: in market 77%, BTC return in -8.0%, out +6.4%.

Threshold neighbours of the winner:

q1 q2 trades total_pct calmar
p10 p50 129 +368.3 8.92
p10 p60 132 +409.6 9.47
p10 p70 130 +416.6 7.33
p20 p50 156 +356.7 9.65
p20 p70 164 +395.3 8.50
p30 p50 189 +344.3 9.30
p30 p60 205 +385.7 12.43
p30 p70 213 +365.6 8.23

Top 10 candidates on dev (>= 71 trades); all 3,888 in candidates.csv:

side f1 op1 q1 f2 op2 q2 trades total_pct max_dd_pts calmar
long oi_chg_24h >= p20 global_ls <= p60 163 +396.0 31.0 12.79
long oi_chg_24h >= p30 global_ls <= p60 205 +385.7 31.0 12.43
long oi_chg_24h >= p40 global_ls <= p60 245 +376.9 30.9 12.19
long funding_rate <= p30 global_ls <= p30 96 +200.4 17.2 11.65
long global_ls <= p40 taker_buy_share >= p70 135 +339.8 30.0 11.33
long global_ls <= p40 taker_buy_share >= p80 142 +321.8 28.6 11.24
long oi_chg_24h <= p60 global_ls <= p40 201 +335.4 30.0 11.17
long funding_rate <= p20 global_ls <= p30 95 +176.5 16.2 10.88
long global_ls <= p70 taker_buy_share <= p20 177 +393.2 36.6 10.75
long oi_chg_24h >= p60 global_ls <= p60 320 +339.3 31.7 10.69

UPDATE