generated 19 Nov 2026 10:57 WIB

Ledger

8 bets: 3 survived, 5 falsified · 8 frames · 7 ideas · 7 rejected.

Every bet was locked in git before its data was computed. Each card links to where it came from and what it led to.

Next up

ideas with no blocker

Do the six frozen positioning-sweep-diverse rules keep beating holding BTC on data after 2026-10-31?
idea · added 2026-11-18
blocker: none; freeze the six rules and thresholds, re-run monthly on new Binance Vision data, decide at 30 portfolio trades (about two months)
from: Does a positioning portfolio of three long and three short rules beat holding BTC from 2025? (survived)
positioning-diverse-forward
Does a wider stop on FOCUSED_TOP_SHARPE, deepput_strike_C14_G09 or iv_deepcall_0804_SL8 make Config B more efficient?
idea · added 2026-11-17
blocker: none; one engine per bet
from: Do LB6's stop-losses pay for themselves? (falsified)
lb6-wider-stop
Are LB6 trades held under 6 hours a loss once engine mix is accounted for?
idea · added 2026-11-17
blocker: none
lb6-short-hold

Survived

bets that passed their locked test

Does a positioning portfolio of three long and three short rules beat holding BTC from 2025?
✓ bet · locked 2026-11-18 23:42 WIB
sweep of 29,160 candidates (btc-perp total so far: 62,208)
portfolio Calmar out of sample: 0.5129 (falsified if <= 0.00 (max of holding BTC, 0))
from: Does a portfolio of positioning rules, built the LB6 way, beat holding BTC from 2025? (falsified)
led to: Do the six frozen positioning-sweep-diverse rules keep beating holding BTC on data after 2026-10-31? (idea)
  Does adding a positioning portfolio to LB6 make it better? (falsified)
positioning-sweep-diverse
Does a grid that follows LB6 beat a plain grid?
✓ bet · locked 2026-11-18 00:23 WIB
Calmar, LB6-directed grid: 2.222 (falsified if <= 0.65 (neutral))
note: with LB6 acted on 0-55 min late, efficiency ranges 0.75-4.83 and beats the best plain grid in 11 of 12 runs (grid-start-sensitivity); up to 2026-08-18 the two grids were close (2.26 vs 2.07); trades 59% of the neutral grid's volume
from: What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
  How much does LB6 trade, and how often does it point one way? (frame)
led to: How much does a simulated grid's result depend on when it starts? (frame)
grid-strike-lb6
Are LB6 trades that go against another engine weaker?
✓ bet · locked 2026-11-17 19:25 WIB
within-engine diff, n-weighted (pp): -0.7689 (falsified if > -0.30); leave-one-engine-out worst diff (pp): -0.4898 (falsified if >= 0)
led to: Should LB6 skip trades that go against another engine? (falsified)
lb6-opposite-weaker

Falsified

bets that failed their locked test

Does adding a positioning portfolio to LB6 make it better?
✗ bet · locked 2026-11-19 00:53 WIB
Calmar, half LB6 + half positioning: 18.8973 (falsified if <= 27.99 (LB6 alone))
from: Does a positioning portfolio of three long and three short rules beat holding BTC from 2025? (survived)
lb6-plus-positioning
Does a portfolio of positioning rules, built the LB6 way, beat holding BTC from 2025?
✗ bet · locked 2026-11-18 23:03 WIB
sweep of 29,160 candidates (btc-perp total so far: 62,208)
portfolio Calmar out of sample: -0.0505 (falsified if <= 0.00 (max of holding BTC, 0))
from: Does the best simple rule on trader positioning beat holding BTC? (falsified)
led to: Does a positioning portfolio of three long and three short rules beat holding BTC from 2025? (survived)
positioning-sweep-lb6
Does the best simple rule on trader positioning beat holding BTC?
✗ bet · locked 2026-11-18 22:04 WIB
sweep of 3,888 candidates (btc-perp total so far: 62,208) · blind data: 2025-01-01..2026-10-31
dev: winner Calmar vs placebo p95: 12.7876 (falsified if <= 9.27); dev: median Calmar of threshold neighbours: 9.1053 (falsified if <= 0); holdout: winner Calmar: -0.3809 (falsified if <= 0.00 (max of buy-and-hold, 0))
led to: Does a positioning sweep that requires gains in most dev years, not one episode, find a rule that lasts? (idea)
  Does a portfolio of positioning rules, built the LB6 way, beat holding BTC from 2025? (falsified)
positioning-sweep
Do LB6's stop-losses pay for themselves?
✗ bet · locked 2026-11-17 23:16 WIB
Calmar, mark-to-market: 11.8526 (falsified if <= 27.99)
led to: Does a wider stop on FOCUSED_TOP_SHARPE, deepput_strike_C14_G09 or iv_deepcall_0804_SL8 make Config B more efficient? (idea)
lb6-no-stop
Should LB6 skip trades that go against another engine?
✗ bet · locked 2026-11-17 19:25 WIB
total net %: 201.638 (falsified if < 239.4); max drawdown (pts): 15.0679 (falsified if > 8.7)
from: Are LB6 trades that go against another engine weaker? (survived)
led to: Does trading opposite entries at half size make Config B more efficient? (idea)
  Do opposite trades offset losses on the position they trade against? (rejected)
lb6-skip-opposite

Frames

measured baselines, no claim

Do Polymarket's 15-minute BTC traders react to BTC's price late?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 20:11 WIB
from: Are Polymarket's 15-minute BTC prices honest probabilities? (frame)
led to: Does buying Polymarket 15-minute Up/Down when a Binance-based probability disagrees with the minute price history make money? (rejected)
  Does a taker who reads BTC within a second and buys Polymarket 15-minute Up/Down when the model disagrees by more than 0.10 make money after fees? (idea)
pm-15m-lag
How much does a simulated grid's result depend on when it starts?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 19:17 WIB
from: What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
  Does a grid that follows LB6 beat a plain grid? (survived)
grid-start-sensitivity
Are Polymarket's 15-minute BTC prices honest probabilities?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 19:14 WIB
led to: Do Polymarket's 15-minute BTC traders react to BTC's price late? (frame)
  Does buying Polymarket 15-minute Up/Down when a Binance-based probability disagrees with the minute price history make money? (rejected)
pm-15m-calibration
Does a thin order book warn of bigger BTC moves and grid stops?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 18:33 WIB
from: What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
  Does order flow when a grid starts warn that it will be stopped out? (frame)
led to: Is a grid that does not start while the order book is thin more efficient? (rejected)
  Is a grid whose step follows the last 24 hours' range more efficient than a fixed-step grid? (rejected)
depth-baseline
Does order flow when a grid starts warn that it will be stopped out?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 15:42 WIB
from: What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
  Does order flow before an LB6 entry say anything about how the trade will go? (frame)
led to: Is a grid that does not start against the last hour's taker flow more efficient? (rejected)
  Does a thin order book warn of bigger BTC moves and grid stops? (frame)
grid-flow-baseline
Does order flow before an LB6 entry say anything about how the trade will go?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 15:37 WIB
led to: Are LB6 trades entered against the last hour's taker flow weaker? (rejected)
  Does order flow when a grid starts warn that it will be stopped out? (frame)
lb6-flow-baseline
What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 00:19 WIB
note: one start time, and a lucky one; over 24 start hours (grid-start-sensitivity) the total ranges -15.5% to -3.7%, middle -6.5%
led to: Is a long-only BTC grid more efficient than a neutral grid before 2026-02-01? (rejected)
  Does a grid that follows LB6 beat a plain grid? (survived)
  Does order flow when a grid starts warn that it will be stopped out? (frame)
  Does a thin order book warn of bigger BTC moves and grid stops? (frame)
  Is a grid whose step follows the last 24 hours' range more efficient than a fixed-step grid? (rejected)
  How much does a simulated grid's result depend on when it starts? (frame)
grid-neutral
How much does LB6 trade, and how often does it point one way?
◆ frame · locked 2026-11-18 00:18 WIB
led to: Does a grid that follows LB6 beat a plain grid? (survived)
lb6-volume-baseline

Blocked ideas

Does a taker who reads BTC within a second and buys Polymarket 15-minute Up/Down when the model disagrees by more than 0.10 make money after fees?
idea · added 2026-11-18
blocker: needs order book (best ask and size) at the moment of the signal, which Polymarket's history does not keep; would have to be recorded live from now, plus the current fee schedule
from: Do Polymarket's 15-minute BTC traders react to BTC's price late? (frame)
pm-15m-fast-taker
Does a positioning sweep that requires gains in most dev years, not one episode, find a rule that lasts?
idea · added 2026-11-18
blocker: no blind BTC data left for this system (2025-01..2026-10 used by positioning-sweep); needs data after 2026-10 to accrue, or another market such as ETH as its own system
from: Does the best simple rule on trader positioning beat holding BTC? (falsified)
positioning-sweep-stable
Does trading opposite entries at half size make Config B more efficient?
idea · added 2026-11-17
blocker: unconfirmed whether sizing is an allowed change (ask pak Yon)
from: Should LB6 skip trades that go against another engine? (falsified)
lb6-half-size-opposite
Does skipping deepdw_iv_M04 entries when net_dw > 0 help?
idea · added 2026-11-17
blocker: low prior; the net_dw effect flips sign across engines (lb6_tool engines, 132 tests)
lb6-m04-netdw-gate

Rejected

dropped ideas, kept so they do not come back

Is a long-only BTC grid more efficient than a neutral grid before 2026-02-01?
rejected: already-seen · added 2026-11-18
reason: answered by grid-neutral without a bet; its BUY half is the long-only grid (Calmar -0.48 vs neutral -0.20 before 2026-02-01), so a bet locked afterwards would not be blind (decided 2026-11-18)
from: What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
grid-long-only
Are LB6 trades entered against the last hour's taker flow weaker?
rejected: low-prior · added 2026-11-18
reason: before 2026-02-01 the difference was -0.21 pp within engine with a 95% CI from -0.75 to +0.41, weaker in only 3 of 6 engines; one engine (deepput_strike_C14_G09, -1.56 pp on 34 trades) carries it, and picking it after seeing six would not be a blind bet (decided 2026-11-18)
from: Does order flow before an LB6 entry say anything about how the trade will go? (frame)
lb6-against-flow-weaker
Is a grid that does not start against the last hour's taker flow more efficient?
rejected: low-prior · added 2026-11-18
reason: before 2026-02-01 grids started against flow ended in a stop only 3 to 5 pp more often, with 95% CIs about 20 pp wide on each side, and stop share showed no trend across flow quintiles; the only holdout left for grids was already used by grid-strike-lb6, so a test would not be blind either (decided 2026-11-18)
from: Does order flow when a grid starts warn that it will be stopped out? (frame)
grid-wait-balanced-flow
Is a grid that does not start while the order book is thin more efficient?
rejected: low-prior · added 2026-11-18
reason: before 2026-02-01 grids started in the thinnest fifth of depth were stopped 7 pp more often than the rest, 95% CI -9 to +25, with no order across the fifths; depth mostly mirrors the last 24 hours' range, which a grid can read from price alone (decided 2026-11-18)
from: Does a thin order book warn of bigger BTC moves and grid stops? (frame)
grid-pause-thin-book
Is a grid whose step follows the last 24 hours' range more efficient than a fixed-step grid?
rejected: low-prior · added 2026-11-18
reason: before 2026-02-01, over 24 start times, a neutral grid with step = mean hourly range of the last 24 hours had median Calmar -0.88 against -0.55 for the fixed 0.5% step, better in 1 of 24 starts; not worth the reserved Sep-Oct 2026 data (decided 2026-11-18)
from: Does a thin order book warn of bigger BTC moves and grid stops? (frame)
  What does a plain BTC grid earn before February 2026? (frame)
grid-step-by-recent-range
Does buying Polymarket 15-minute Up/Down when a Binance-based probability disagrees with the minute price history make money?
rejected: true-by-construction · added 2026-11-18
reason: the minute price history trails BTC by about a minute while trades trail it by about 3 s (pm-15m-lag), so the +0.18 per share seen on minute points comes from late-recorded points, not from prices anyone could trade (decided 2026-11-18)
from: Are Polymarket's 15-minute BTC prices honest probabilities? (frame)
  Do Polymarket's 15-minute BTC traders react to BTC's price late? (frame)
pm-15m-minute-edge
Do opposite trades offset losses on the position they trade against?
rejected: true-by-construction · added 2026-11-17
reason: true by construction; all engines trade the same BTC, so a long and a short open together always offset (decided 2026-11-17)
from: Should LB6 skip trades that go against another engine? (falsified)
lb6-opposite-hedge